Mom's Secret Natural Gel Eyeliner Black, Vegan, Organic, Made in the USA

Really awesome, but it’s pretty touchy with temperature so keep that in mind.It started out with a creamy, easy-to-apply texture but after heating and cooling multiple times it has hardened to the point of being pretty difficult to apply, and when it is applied, it goes on light. I don't mind, I'm not very picky when it comes to eye makeup (I tend to do liner on the upper lid with no mascara or eyeshadow) and touch up with some face paint I use as eye makeup to get a nice crisp edge on the outer parts.I don't wear eye makeup very often, but when I do use this I apply on my upper lid (my upper lid is pretty big compared to many, though) and it has lasted me nearly a year if not longer than that! I still have about a third of it left (but again, I don't wear eye makeup very often anymore)The ingredients are all pretty tame however, which is a nice deviation from your typical carcinogens in regular eye makeup.If you care about ingredients and can keep it relatively the same temperature year round, get it! You'll be amazed by the ease of application and staying power! ❤️🧡💛💚💙💜

This was a gloppy mess and wouldn't even stay on my eyelid. Generally gel eyeliner is applied with a brush. This was waxy and wouldn't even pick up on the brush, let alone glide on to my skin.

Nice texture and seems to dry well, yet still gives me raccoon eyes. Wish it wouldn’t smudge quite so much

It goes on thick and gloppy. I wanted to smudge it to a not as black line, but it won't work. Plus it's very hard, and I don't know what you could thin it with to get a smudgy line.

Lasts long

This is my second order of Mom's Secret eyeliner! I've tried so many different eyeliners and this one is by far my favorite. I love how it draws on easy and stays all day. The eyeliner, along with the mascara, doesn't irritate my eyes either as other brands do.

It is dry and does not stay on well at all. You cannot moisten it with water.

I really like this eyeliner. Best I have used. Goes on easy and stays on all day. I have had a hard time finding one I like and it being organic.