When Pencil Met Gel Sharpenable Multi-Use Longwear Eyeliner Pencil - Soft Black - Transfer-Proof - High Performance Liner.

I was looking for something that waterproof but great way make the eye to appear more refreshed. Being an older person, my eyes look more tired and I always used black eyeliner and mascara. I love how easy this is to apply to the eye. am in love with the color being I have always used black, I think black on a olde person doesnt do great for the eyes. This color was a better choice. With already dark brown eye it was a great choice and the size of the product was small. I think it was a prtetty good size and the price was affordable. What I also loved about this product it can last all day wear . This is a set up for myself in trying to find a product that lasts and a still help the older eyes from looking more refreshed then making them look older and tired. I recommend trying the bronze color..My favorite.

I love that it stays on. very smooth application and I love the charcoal. It is softer than dark black.

Suprisingly good eyeliner! Glides on, has staying power, and good color pigmentation. I usually either use eyeshadow on my eyeliner to set it, or set it with a setting spray (or both), and I have not experienced smudging or flaking. My only complaint is that it does not sharpen to a fine point even using the Julep sharpener, but that's not a deal breaker for me.

I really like the color of this pencil and it goes on easily. Stays where I apply it. Good product.

I hope this would be a cool dark brown. It swatched that way, but upon wearing just under an hour it was like the color faded?? It was just grayish. I was wearing it alone, so no idea how that happened. It didn't want to glide on my waterline. It was a fight to get it to stay. And when it did finally, the feeling on my eyes was really heavy and sticky. Every blink feels like the stickiest lip gloss idk how else to describe it. I was considering trying a different color, but the way this feels on my eyes I can't justify it. Besides that though, no irritation, which was nice. I have sensitive eyes and it didn't bother my eyes like that at all. And, it seemed to have some staying power. It didn't smudge or transfer much at all, and it stayed where I put it.

I love this eyeliner but why don't they try to sell the sharpener? I almost threw mine away because I thought it was finished! It did not come with instructions or to to sharpen as needed or anything. They are missing huge market sales at 13.00 a pop. I wonder how many people are as clueless as I was??? I love this eyeliner and I want to buy ALL the colors now...but I almost wrote of the entire line based on my experience thinking I had to throw it away so quickly! Haha I'm so glad I looked at the description online again before I did. My sharpener arrives tomorrow! Hooray! It truly feels like a gel pen.. I'm thinking no way this is a pencil to sharpen .. it's that different from normal pencils. Try it! Goes on soooooooo easy on my mature eyes.

One of the best pencils I’ve tried. Glides on easily without pulling/tugging, and once you give it 30-45 seconds to set it’s smudgeproof and long-lasting. Zero eye irritation with this brand. The pencils are long and easy to keep sharp with a good sharpener (I prefer e.l.f. brand eye pencil sharpener). Great value for your money

Made in Germany. This is a really nice green. The tip broke off upon opening but it sharpened back up nice. As long as it doesn't constantly brake in the future will update if it does. Soft liners are better anyways.