Taffy TownSaltwater Taffy, Cotton Candy, 2.5Lb

Taffy Town's Cotton Candy Saltwater Taffy is an absolute treat! The texture is soft, chewy, and buttery-smooth—no jaw workout required. And the flavor? Pure nostalgic perfection. It genuinely tastes like fresh cotton candy, with just the right balance of sweetness and melt-on-your-tongue charm. The pastel colors are super cute too, making it perfect for party favors, candy jars, or adding a playful touch to gift baskets. Whether you're grabbing a bag for yourself or sharing, this taffy brings smiles with every bite.

Great cinnamon flavor. Harry is fresh and soft. This is second purchase. Never disappointed with their quality.

Great

This is my 3rd purchase. Thai time it came all melted together. Unable to open pieces. Try to get a replacement and it says not able to return or replace. So basically I wasted my $25.

3rd time ordering these licorice taffy....I enjoy them very much ....good licorice flavor

*** UPDATED ON MARCH 4TH*** I decided to order directly from Taffy Town to compare the two products side by side tastewise. I am disappointed to say that the taffy that came directly from the Taffy Town had a very faint peppermint flavor as well. I do extend my apologies to the seller who told me they got their product from Taffy Town in that condition. Seller did get kinda ugly with me during the process, but they were just defending their product...I get it. But if you like actual peppermint flavor I would get a different one NOT made by Taffy Town. On the other hand their cinnamon flavor is VERY GOOD and cinnaminny!I love doing reviews and try to be as honest as I can be for the sellers here. I do NOT apologize for being honest with my reviews. #blessednotstressedORIGINAL REVIEW: Very soft and salt watery, but no flavor of the peppermint. Buyer cannot return this type of item. Seller did not respond in a timely manner, I had to reach out twice to get a response. Seller stated I basically would need to reach out to Taffy Town for a response on the flavor. I can only conclude that maybe the maker or the seller had these on the shelf for a very long time for the flavor to be gone. I am pretty sure taffy town is a great taffy maker and has good quality, but I can't guarantee how long the seller had these in their possession. Take my and other reviews seriously if it states that the taste isn't correct.

Have been purchasing Taffy Town taffy from retailers for years and finally discovered I could get it any time I want via Amazon. I love the chocolate flavored taffy and found I could get it without ordering an assortment of flavors. Totally happy with my purchase!

So I’ll divide this into 2 parts; taffy & cinnamon. As a taffy, it delivered as you’d expect. It’s slightly more chewy than salt water taffy but not by much. Where it failed for me was the flavor intensity. To provide some context, I relate cinnamon flavors against cinnamon altoid mints. When I tried my first taffy, the flavor started building as I chewed & had a similar flavor as the mints but the intensity was WAY short of the mark. Approximately 1/3-1/4 the intensity of a single mint. For someone who enjoys 3-4 at once, it was very disappointing. If you like “hot” cinnamon flavor but always find that the flavor is too strong, then these taffys are for you. If you like atomic fireballs, you won’t even notice this.