Bumkins Disposable Cloth Fabric Diaper Liner, Biodegradable, Neutral, 100 Count (Pack of 1)

These are wonderful. Very soft on baby, nice and big - we use the FLIP diapers with inserts, and you can kind of wrap these around the insert, just make sure they're tucked in. Very little poop ever gets on the diaper shell. They flush down well, and if you happen to leave one on a diaper in the wash, it rolls up into neat little strings that you can easily toss.The fact that they don't stand up to washing, i.e., aren't "reusable" is a huge PLUS in my book! Think about it. Do you really want to flush something down your pipes that can stand up to two long wash cycles? I would be seriously worried about clogging my pipes.

I started cloth diapering about a month ago and have been putting these liners in my kids diapers every time. They work really well at keeping the actual poop off of the insert which makes for a much easier cleanup. When my kids poop I just take the insert to the bathroom, plop the liner off into the toilet, and put my insert into my wet bag and I am done. They are a generous size as well! My friend has some other brand of liner which comes on a roll like toilet paper and the width of hers is so skinny compared to bumkins. I have had to clean a number of blowouts, and I am not so sure if it's the liner moving around or just my daughters astronomical bowel movements, because it only ever seems to be her diapers and not my sons. As far as the average user using 4-6 100 pack boxes of these is bologna. I have two kids, age 2 1/2 and 6 months who just finished their first 100 pack box in a week shy of a month. So two boxes a month should be plenty unless you have 3 in diapers. I have decided to go ahead and get a bidet cloth diaper sprayer for my toilet so as to save even more money diapering my kids, but I will continue to use these liners when we are away from home for convenience.

I ordered both the Bumkins liners and the Bummis Bio-Soft in order to compare the two and see which I preferred.The differences I noticed most about the Bumkins were:Larger (can actually split each sheet into 2 if you have the patience to do that, making the box last twice as long)Noticeably softerPop-up style, like a tissue box, seems easier for one-handed use than the Bummis tear-off sheets. In practice, however, I found that it made little difference, because I still needed 2 hands to get the liner properly folded and positioned on the diaper! For this reason, I generally find it easiest to get the liner out and position it in the new diaper before I take the old diaper off of the baby.Bummis pros:Smaller footprint on the changing space (a consideration for us because we have limited space there)Also large enough to possibly split into 2 liners per sheet for a smaller baby, but not for a larger oneBoth brands seem to flush equally well, and both do an excellent job of staying in place. I cloth diapered without liners for my previous baby and with this baby until he started solids, but I definitely prefer the ease the flushable liners add and wouldn't go back to not using them at this point unless we had a septic system that couldn't handle the flushable liners. I do recommend letting the soiled liners sit in the toilet for a couple of minutes or more before flushing -- it supposedly helps them break down more easily and reduce the likelihood of clogging the toilet, though in practice I've never had either brand's usage result in a toilet clog.All in all, I do slightly prefer the softer feel of the Bumkins, but the differences are minor, and I like the smaller footprint for the Bummis. For personal preference the Bumkins win out by a hair, but both brands are similar enough that I wouldn't hesitate to buy either.

I have only just started using liners now that my baby has started solid foods and her stools are becoming more formed. (Breast-fed baby poo is the consistency of yogurt and simply washes out in a cold pre-wash). My main concern when choosing a liner was "flushability" in regards to a septic system, especially since my house was built in 1978. Logic dictates that if you can wash and re-use a liner, it probably is not going to break up sufficiently for an older septic system to handle properly (as evidenced by the many reviews of other liners stating problems with clogs). Hence the reason I decided to try these liners - because of the complaints that they were thin and flimsy! So far, I have only flushed the poopy liners and have not had any problems with clogs.PLEASE NOTE: These liners CANNOT be washed and re-used, they will stretch out like cheesecloth and become unusable if put through the wash.These liners are very soft and thin, nice and wide, and are very stretchy. I have not had a problem with them bunching up or disintegrating in the diaper at all as some reviewers have. They are large and I do have to fold them over about an inch fit inside the AIOs, but that's just fine with me. The poop tends to stick more to the liner than baby's bottom, which makes cleanup easy. The liners do tend to stick to baby's skin, especially on hot days when sweaty or if the diaper is not changed in a timely fashion and gets completely soaked. They can stick together when trying to pull them out of the box, but this is a minor inconvenience to me. I like that I can grab a bunch together and keep them in the diaper bag for on-the-go.

It catches my daughters poo in her cloth diaper but it does easiliy bunch up and stick to her area. no irritation though.