Physicians Formula Argan Wear Ultra-nourishing Argan Oil Kohl Kajal Eyeliner, Ultra Black, 0.09 Ounce

I’ve had authentic, really dark eyeliner out of the Middle East before and I thought maybe this would be the same. Sure, it has pretty Arabic-looking packaging (which is what persuaded me to buy it in the first place) but don’t let that fool you. If the product worked as good it’s container looks, I would’ve given it 5⭐️. It’s not that dark and quite frankly doesn’t apply as dark as my $1 pencil. I won’t be buying another one, but will be buying 7 of the cheaper $1 pencils instead, as they are MUCH cheaper & MUCH darker, & I like my eye pencils Super dark. So disappointing, but cute to have on my vanity🤷🏽‍♀️ I gave it 4⭐️ since this product is easy to use and easy clean off with micellar water.

This is easy to apply, goes on smoothly & looks good. I did find that using a setting powder over it with another light application over the powder helps it last longer without fading or smearing. I've been using this for a couple of years since it came out and keep coming back to it since it looks like a more natural liner than most of the liquids & thinner pencils out there although if you want to do a dramatic eye with this liner, you easily could. My eyes are a little sensitive & this product doesn't seem to trigger any adverse reactions like other drug store type brands often do.

The color on this is great. Like the other reviewers have said, the actual eyeliner cone tends to fall out. Knowing this, and because this is the only affordable blackeyeliner I've found that doesn't sting my eyes, rub off, and actually lasts on my very oily eyelids, I've learned to deal with it. I don't twist my eyeliner all the way up and I make sure when I pull the cap off that the eyeliner straight up so the black eyeliner cone doesn't actually fall out. I do wish the design was better, but it's not such a big deal that I can't use it.

I have super sensitive eyes. This doesn’t irritate or make my eyes teary. I wear contacts and other eyeliners don’t do well on my waterline. But this one is amazing. I can even poke my eye accidentally with it, and it doesn’t bother my contact or eye. It glides on soooo smooth. Only take away is that it will smudge if you rub it. Keep your hands away from your eyes, lol. But I love the darkness and ease of putting it on. Overall good but. I got this with the matching ultra black mascara. Perfect combination.

It's dark black. It looks nice on my eye, but it doesn't stay long, and by time it gets out of my eye and looks little missy. It is also not so easy to apply, and the tip is not fixed to the bottom. I'm not very disappointed, but I won't buy again.

I love the boldness the color brings out in my eyes. Shows a beautiful, sexy and sensual look. Can create thick lines or thin. Good for the water line or lids. Use a primer or powder compact under the eye to reduce the spread of the tint. Oh, by the way, it does not irritate my eyes.

It's a good product but has the tendency to run. So a little goes long way

Goes on nice and dark, but starts to smudge within the first few hours. The product broke off after a few days of use. It can get messy if not being extra careful. Anyways, I will look into another brand for kohl eyeliner. This one doesn’t make the second purchase cut... 👌😂