Mistine Natural Brown Eyeliner All Day Smudge Proof and Waterproof Eyeliner with Felt Brush Tip, Vegan & Cruelty Free, Matte Finish Liquid Eyeliner 0.04 Fl Oz

This liner works fabulously! I only use a very small amount right on my lash line (almost into my waterline) and it seems to last all day for me (as long as I'm not rubbing my eyes during allergy season of course). It's a beautiful and smooth!

The black one is nice and is working..the brown one is seems to be old stock. It is nothing inside. Check your item if it is still good or not before sending them please I am just wasting money on it.

The product stays on well abd glides smoothly. The applicator is a little rigid but I'm sure it will hold up well over time. The shade was lighter than what I needed but still a great product. If you are looking for a dark brown though, this is not the shade.

Stila stay all day was my HG. I keep trying other brands to see if I could save money using a similar product and truly, this one compares! This is the longest lasting, most water resistant and smudge proof liquid eyeliner I’ve ever used. The felt tip works well for application, compared to other brands, the tip doesn’t dry out very quickly though. I never have issues with flaking or irritation. Sometimes it has a hard time applying over other products so I tend to do eyeliner first and then reapply if needed. I don’t use primer or fixer though so maybe that would help.

Smudge proof for me yes. For other commenting no. Water, saliva, or tear proof not at all. It’s so easy and nice light brown. Other then that will not buy again.

I'm in love with this eyeliner. I am able to go to work, run errands, go to the gym and never worry about the state of my eyeliner. I sweat very easily so my liner was always running/smudging (even with other apparent waterproof liners). But now, I don't have to worry about that anymore. Plus it comes off easily with makeup remover. This will be a new constant in my makeup box. I am though, still seeing how long the product takes to run out with everday use.

The color is very light brown, so it doesn’t show very much when applied. Will not buy again.

There aren’t any ink at all