Top Dog Chews - Thick 12 Inch Bully Sticks, 100% Natural Beef, Free Range, Grass Fed, High Protein, Supports Dental Health & Easily Digestible, Dog Treat, 10 Pack

My 4Ib Chihuahua loves these! I wouldn't say these are jumbo sized. They were (mostly, some were a teeny bit thicker than ideal) the perfect size for her and shes tiny. 1 bully stick lasts for about 3 weeks, sometimes longer depending on her moods. I don't see these lasting that long for a bigger puppy. More like stinky snacks.These are so stinky. It makes her face smell and where she licks me stinks horribly. Luckily, the odor around her mouth/face goes away after an hour or so. I purchased one bully stick from the pet store and the odor was minimal. But she prefers the stinkiest one over the pet store one. I usually put up the bully sticks when people come over so she isn't smelly and doesn't stinky lick our company.All in all, other than smell. We love em and so does she. I'd probably buy these again unless I find a better deal elsewhere.

The dog loves these and I love the price. That said, don't expect them to be 'odor free.' They are not. It's not horrible, but even before the dog starts working on one, they do have a slight odor - more once they get wet from chewing. I don't notice it, but others in my house do not care for the smell.But, the important thing is that the dog loves them and they keep him busy for a while! Delivery was prompt, and like I said the price is nice.

My lab puppy really liked these. He is a big chewer, if he is awake he is chewing on something. But when it comes to bones and chews he is very picky and he has doggy ADHD I think because he never sits and chews anything longer than a few minutes. With these he lays there and chews and chews. These last for a very long time. They do have a gross smell but I don't care. It's worth it just to keep him occupied for awhile.

The chews are not thick at all. I think maybe they are mislabeled. I’ll forward a picture. My golden can eat in about 7 minutes. I have had other ones that were much thicker and took much longer to chew

Dog loved these but they seriously stunk everyone out of our house. These were absolutely outdoor only bully sticks!

My dog absolutely loves these bully sticks and prefers them over any other treat. They work good to keep teeth clean too.

nice but can be ate in a 1/2 hour.

I think my dogs just go through things too fast. Maybe if these were 15" long and three times as thick? They made good little snacks, but for real chewing, I have had to stick with knuckle bones.