Silly George Heart Eyes Mascara - Waterproof Mascara Black Suitable for Sensitive Eyes | Mascara For Volumising & Lengthening | Tubing Mascara Smudge Free, Grudge Free Lashes, Cruelty Free & Vegan 7ml

Great mascara, my new bestie!! Good value as it lasts ages! No flakes or clumps but easy to remove . Highly recommend

I hoped this mascara would be good, but by mid-morning there was a smudge of mascara above each eye. I'd been concentrating on some work and I must have been frowning and screwing up my eyes a bit attending to the detail, and there was smudging where the ends of my upper lashes had touched my upper eyelids. No smudging under my lower lashes, though. Unfortunately, I also found that tiny fibres from the mascara were somehow getting into my eyes and irritating them and my contact lenses, which got worse as the day went on. I found a few more tiny black bits of mascara in my eyes the following morning before I put my lenses in again, even though I'd rinsed my eyes with saline solution the night before. I've decided not to use this mascara again, and I'm going back to Aveda Mosscara.

Love this mascara, it has two different wands in one so you can opt for thicker lashes if you want. It also comes off in clumps when you take it off which I prefer. Deserves 5 stars

Didn't do much for lashes.

Not a bad mascara. Points for the volume and the length wands . Did find that it smudges on me. Easy to remove . Didn’t blow me away but not the worst mascara

Sorry but this did not work for me . Black smudge under my eyes within an hour

This is the best mascara I can remember using for a long time, and probably the best of the more ethical brands. I generally just use the first lid and not a fan of thick lashes. But this one lengthens my lashes really nicely and separates them well so no clumping even after a clumsy second coat. My only complaint is it seems to be drying out or perhaps running out quickly, but then maybe that is because I have actually continued using it. It has good staying power so takes some effort to remove at times, although if stubborn a drop of facial oil generally helps with softening up stubborn mascara. Well worth a try.

I am always on the look out for smudge free mascara, cause most days I end up looking something like Alice Cooper! But not with this, two different wands in one for different effects.Does not smudge and really easily removed with wipes or cleanser. Will be my mascara staple from now on .

It’s one of the very best mascaras that I’ve try it! So the same day I received it I got a Gucci mascara from Sephora so I tried them both same time different eyes and WOW this one way better than Gucci and any other one I have. I can say it’s very similar to one of my MAC but can’t remember the name however this one is better because it’s not like a glue!! You can remove it easily without smashing your eyes 😅 I remove it with Clinique take the day off then a bit of micellar water just to make sure everything is clean before I use my white towel. It gives great volume. However, it’s not an extension so don’t expect it to be that great if you initially have short think lashes. It’s so great for someone with medium/long straight lashes so it will make it look more curly and longer.

I like the volume and length that I can achieve with the Silly George Heart Eyes Mascara. I can quickly create a "false lashes" look and build the length and volume that I prefer. This is a dual wand mascara and I use the first wand to coat my lashes and the second to refine and add length. I prefer mascara that has one easy-to-use wand. The mascara has been harder than ideal to remove. I have to use one particular cleanser that removes makeup with minimal effort. It truly has been smudge-free and budge-free as described but removal is not as easy as described. If you are looking for a lash building mascara that stays in place, this is a good choice.

I love this mascara! I won’t have to look any further. It lengthens and curls, doesn’t smudge or clump, and washes off easily, no need for eye makeup remover.

The media could not be loaded.  This mascara is not horrible but also not great. It's a very watery formula and seems to clump easily. It does dry down but smudges some throughout the day. I do like the option of brushes but there is not a huge difference between them. I wanted to like it more than I actually do.

Absolutely love this mascara. I have oily skin and this mascara does not smudge at all. I love that there’s two options of wand types. I’ve been using this mascara for awhile now. Lasts a long time.