Wavelets and Filter Banks
M**R
The legend at his best
Ok. I am divulging a secret here. This book is a hidden Gem, who never actually realized its potential, it seems. It packs so much crucial / critical information about DSP, multirate techniques, filter design, multirate system optimization that its simply incredible !!! I however agree with the reviews which rate its difficulty high, and a reviewer claiming that it has been written in bouts of inspiration. I can associate with him, and yet, associate more with the authors, when they set about writing on this topic. Its a huge undertaking for one. The literature was/is exploding all the time. To give a composite picture, they are freaking hard pressed. No wonder, people find it tiring, and give up before they could realize what a gem of a creation it is. Gilbert strang, is really at his best here. He is plunging left , right and center, grasping concepts in his solid hands, and massaging them for palatability. I found the book intimidating too, at first, but looked at other texts. The gaps that others would always leave, this book would come in and fill them, not only fill them, but solidify them, re-enforce them with pure concrete.Since I said I will be divulging , here is my advice on people starting out with it. Dont take the progression of book too seriously. Its not that its flawed, its just that one cannot appreciate its beauty at the outset. So , do not cover the material as it presents itself. Atleast not the whole of it. And there can be different points of emphasis for people approaching from different directions, but generally, try to glean important DSP details, and leave the multiresolution stuff for a later date. One should keep coming back to it every now and then, and you would see it makes more sense. Chapter three, four and five. And most expecially FOUR. Thats the meat of the book, and truly striking. But to get struck, you have to be listening closely to him in Chapter 2. Chapter 3 is a meticulous, nowhere ever to be found treatment of sampling with z operators. Pay very close attention. Once you hit Chapter 4 then, you will be able to appreciate the perfect reconstruction framework. Chapter 4 then trails off, and emphasized alias cancellation a little too much. Again no fault of authors, just the way things stand in literature. Kind of misses the perfect reconstruction condition, and finishes off introducing polyphase notation. You have to keep in mind that perfect reconstruction conditions still need to be satisfied and hence all the later chapters. Keep coming back to three and two whenever you feel you are getting lost.I suggest Vitterli's subband coding and Fred Harris multirate communications are very helpful texts to go with it, for people implementing with a practical flavor in mind. Esp Fred Harris gives a totally striking transciever view of the whole theory. Can help tie things together more beautifully.In short, the reviews dont quite do justice to this momentous text. Its trully striking. Its truly a work of love. And absolutely dead instructive. Instruction doesnt get any better.
C**Y
Good book for a select few.
Pretty thick stuff, but for what I want, it's pretty good.
O**K
Excellent text
A unique (?) book on all manner of statistical filters. Written in lecture-note style, not as smooth as some texts. Authoritative. The filter-bank interpretation of wavelet methods is particularly useful.
E**D
Great Text/Reference
I have taken several courses on DSP. I found that this text takes topics that were presented, expanded them in great detail. It took some of the mystery out of my previous presentations. Anyone working with DSP should have this on their shelf!
I**N
Very specialized but not a good book for wavelets
I have this book for a wavelet course. I find this book cryptic and not very easy to learn about wavelets.
D**N
Five Stars
Really great quality for the price.
P**N
Engineers need math, but on their terms.
At many US universities, math departments offer service courses in math for the engineers, and there is a periodic discussion of the curriculum. One difficulty is that the two sides speak different languages;-- in math, it is linear algebra, calculus...,- and in engineering, signals, high-pass/low-pass filters, downsampling/upsampling, filter bank, polyphase matrix...A wonderful feature of the Strang-Nguyen book is that it speaks both languages. In this way it is refreshing, and it stands outin a class of its own. It has been tested in courses for engineers, and stood the test. From what I hear, it is equally popular in the two cultures, math and engineering.
S**I
good book for a wavelet beginner
The book start from very basic concept, and then step by step lead you to wavelet, and end at applications.You need only undergraduate level DSP knowledge to learn this.
Trustpilot
3 weeks ago
5 days ago