Natural Farm Collagen Dog Chews (12 Inch, 5 Pack), Odor-Free Long Lasting Bully Sticks & Rawhide Alternative Dog Treats, 95% Collagen Low Fat, High Protein Best Dental Dog Treats – Medium & Large Dogs

Like: Came quickly and efficiently. My dog loves them and will happily chew for about a half hour. They also do not have any smell to them.Dislike: I would prefer a mix that didn't have animal protein or at the least, the protein was hydrolyzed since my pup has GI issues. Also, the sticks are very varied on size...some are pencil thin, while others are an inch in diameter.

The dogs love these! They'll last for several hours with a small dog. Larger dogs not so much, but nothing lasts long with larger dogs. Still though, they do keep them busy for a good long while. I don't give my dogs rawhides in general because I don't think they're especially healthy, but these seem highly digestible. None of my three dogs have any problems with them at all...chewing, swallowing or after they're done. They like these as much as bully sticks, but for a fraction of the price thank goodness!

So I cut these large sticks into thirds, 1 for each of my 3 dogs, keeps them occupied. for awhile, they do not stink, healthy for them, great quality, and thickness they have plenty to chew on. Great size, they love the taste

Purchased these because our dog was destroying Nylabones for powerful chewers and was having bloody stool due to the shards in his intestines! So much for Nylabones being touted as “safe” ($700+ ER vet bills & many other vet visits and bills when it was the unknown cause!!)Love: our dog loves these - he wasn’t sure when presented but once he figured out it was on! Very little scent. No discoloration of my floor thus far. Glad it is using animal byproducts that are not going to waste. He loves chewing so hopefully this product will be the one that substitutes for Nylabones.Meh: I gave it to him less than an hour ago and he is 1/2 thru it already. I can see we will have to watch him and take it away when it gets close to done.Boo: seems expensive - but I give the benefit of the doubt that despite this being a beef byproduct, it likely takes a bit of time and/or is labor intensive compared to other chews. There is a 1/4 stick waste per chew if you don’t allow your dog to eat the whole thing (we can’t because he is little and it can get lodged in his GI and cause a block) which means for the price you are getting only 75% of your value.

The quality of the bully sticks are great and our dog loves them. A lot better than our pet store. And the price is also cheaper than our pet stores. Definitely worth the money and highly recommend.

Durable for big chewers

I have these on reorder because my dog loved them and gets one a day. I initially liked these because there was low odor compared to bully sticks with the same chew time and convenience at a lower price.Lately the quality has been hit or miss. As you can see, one or both of the ends can 'bloom' and become brittle. The dog loses interest once this happens.The size is also getting more inconsistent. Some are too thick for our medium holder (I use our yak cheese holder for those). I had to get a small holder to accommodate the thin sticks, which there seems to be more of now. We've had a couple sticks over multiple bags that were a little too thin for the small holder. Usually you can find a spot in the middle of the stick that secures in the holder; now at the risk of a double end bloom/frustrating release when it's done.I also had one bag over the summer that STANK! worse than bully sticks. Though the dog still ate them.

I've been using two different brands of collagen chews because both were often out of stock. My dog has decided that Natural Farm's are much better. This morning, I gave her one of the other brand. She took it, walked a few steps away, dropped it, and came back in her usual "I want a dog chew" stance. I tried a few other things to see if there was something else she wanted. I realized I still had one chew of this brand, so I gave that to her. She took it, laid down next to the other brand's and had a grand time with the Natural Farm chew while completely ignoring the other brand's. She has spoken!

Last a long time